Five Reasons Why You Shouldn’t Rely Solely on ChatGPT to Write Your Contracts

With the rise of AI tools like ChatGPT, businesses and individuals are increasingly turning to technology for assistance with a variety of tasks, including contract drafting. While AI can certainly be helpful, it’s important to understand the risks and limitations of relying solely on a tool like ChatGPT to write your contracts. Here are five key reasons why doing so could expose you to legal and financial risks:

1. Lack of Legal Expertise and Customization

While ChatGPT can generate text that sounds legally sound, it lacks the deep understanding of specific legal principles, case law, and jurisdictional nuances that human lawyers provide. Contracts require more than just filling in blanks; they demand a keen awareness of how certain terms and clauses will be interpreted by courts. AI lacks the experience to assess the complexities of individual cases and cannot tailor the contract to the unique needs of your business, especially in highly regulated industries.

Example: A non-compete clause written by AI might sound comprehensive, but it may not be enforceable in certain states or may omit critical language that would protect your business interests.

2. Outdated Legal Knowledge

Laws change frequently, and new court rulings constantly reshape how contractual terms are interpreted. ChatGPT does not have real-time access to the latest changes in legislation or case law. While it can provide information up to a certain point in time, it won’t keep up with recent amendments or judicial decisions that could impact the enforceability of your contract.

Example: ChatGPT could include a provision that was valid under previous case law, but recent rulings may have declared similar terms unenforceable, potentially voiding the entire agreement.

3. Courts Assess Fairness and Reasonableness

Courts look beyond just the wording of a contract—they assess the fairness and reasonableness of the terms when deciding whether to enforce it. ChatGPT lacks the ability to evaluate whether a provision would hold up in court, especially when it comes to equitable doctrines like unconscionability (when terms are overly one-sided or oppressive).

Example: ChatGPT may create a penalty clause for breach of contract that’s disproportionately harsh compared to the harm caused. A court might consider such a clause unreasonable and refuse to enforce it, leaving you without a remedy.

4. Complexity of Industry-Specific Regulations

Many industries are governed by highly specific regulations, and contracts in those fields need to be crafted with an in-depth understanding of those rules. AI-generated contracts may miss key industry-specific language, compliance requirements, or disclosures that could lead to regulatory fines, disputes, or voided agreements.

Example: In the financial services industry, failing to include specific language around fiduciary duties, reporting obligations, or compliance with Anti-Money Laundering (AML) laws could result in regulatory penalties or loss of licensure.

5. Inability to Provide Strategic Legal Advice

Contract drafting isn’t just about writing legally sound language; it’s about strategy. Human lawyers don’t just draft; they negotiate, assess risk, and strategize based on the client’s specific goals and circumstances. ChatGPT, on the other hand, cannot offer strategic advice on negotiation tactics, risk allocation, or how to structure agreements to best protect your interests.

Example: In a merger or acquisition, a lawyer might advise on adding indemnity clauses, representations, and warranties to protect the buyer. ChatGPT would simply generate a template based on a prompt, potentially leaving key protections out.

Conclusion

While ChatGPT can be a helpful tool for drafting simple documents or providing a starting point, relying solely on it to write your contracts is a risky move. A contract is more than just a set of terms—it’s a legally binding agreement that can have long-lasting financial and legal consequences. Always consult with a qualified attorney who understands the nuances of your business and the law to ensure that your contracts are enforceable, reasonable, and aligned with your business objectives.

Need a Legal Eye to Look at Something? Contact us today to get started or submit your document for review.